Search for:
Member Login
My Profile
Renew Your Membership
AAPORnet Listserv
Membership Directory
Retrieve Password
Logout
The leading association
of public opinion and
survey research professionals
American Association for Public Opinion Research
My AAPOR
+
My Profile
Renew Your Membership
AAPORnet Listserv
Membership Directory
Retrieve Password
Logout
Membership
+
Join AAPOR
Membership Options
Online Dues Renewal
Online Member Application
Volunteer
Chapters
Midwest (MAPOR)
New England (NEAAPOR)
New York (NYAAPOR)
Pacific (PAPOR)
Pennsylvania-New Jersey (PANJAAPOR)
Southern (SAPOR)
Washington, DC (DC-AAPOR)
Affinity Groups
Cross-cultural and multilingual research affinity group
GAAPOR
HISP-AAPOR
Survey Research Teaching Affinity and Interest Group
QUALPOR
AAPI Research & Affinity Group
Membership Directory
For Students
Graduate Degree Programs
Sudman Student Paper Competition
Membership Research
Publications/Media
+
AAPOR Publications
Public Opinion Quarterly
JSSAM
Survey Practice
Standard Definitions
Reports
AAPOR Newsletter
Newsletter Archives
AAPOR Press Releases
Archived Press Releases
AAPOR Statements
Use of AAPOR Logo
Conference/Events
+
View Calendar
COVID-19 Workshop Series
Annual Conference
Registration
AAPOR Swag Shop
Message from the Conference Chairs
Mini-Conference
Short Courses
Interactive Schedule
Schedule at a Glance
Exhibits and Sponsorship
Sustaining Sponsorship
Social Media Kit
Presenter and Moderator Guidelines
Attendee Technical Guidelines
2021 Conference FAQs
Terms of Agreement
Media Policy
Conference Location Selection Process
Upcoming Conferences
SurveyFest
Past Conferences
2019 Annual Conference Videos
AAPOR Awards
Award Winners
AAPOR Award
Book Award
Inclusive Voices Award
Warren J. Mitofsky Innovators Award
Policy Impact Award
Public Service Award
Seymour Sudman Student Paper Competition
Roper Fellow Award
Student Conference Award
AAPOR Returning Member Travel Award
Student Poster Award
The Student-Faculty Diversity Pipeline Award
Monroe G. Sirken Award
Harkness Student Paper Competition
Standards/Ethics
+
AAPOR Code of Professional Ethics and Practices
Proposed Code Changes
Disclosure Standards
Survey Disclosure Checklist
Schedule of Procedures for Code Violations
Transparency Initiative
What is the TI?
How to Join the TI
Current Members
Educational Materials
Your TI Application
Contact the TICC
Updates Archive
Institutional Review Boards
AAPOR Guidance for IRBs and Survey Researchers
IRB FAQs for Survey Researchers
Consent
Additional IRB Resources
Standard Definitions
Response Rate Calculator
Condemned Survey Practices
RDD Phone Survey Introduction
Best Practices for Survey Research
Report an AAPOR Code Violation
Education/Resources
+
Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA)
Election Polling Resources
Online Education/Webinars
Webinars
My Webinars
Purchase Recordings
AAPOR Webinar Package FAQs
AAPOR Webinar Kits
Institutional Subscriptions
Webinars FAQ
Professional Researcher Certification
Send-a-Speaker
AAPOR-JPSM Citation Program
AAPOR-JPSM Citation Registration
Reports
Career Center
For Researchers
For Media
Response Rate Calculator
About Us
+
Leadership
Committees and Taskforces
Executive Council Meeting Minutes
Past Presidents
Annual Reports
Executive Council Election
History
Heritage Interviews
A Meeting Place and More
"Back in the Olden Days"
Presidential Addresses
AAPOR Archives Highlights
AAPOR Interactive Timeline sponsored by NORC
T-Shirt Contest Winners
Who We Are
Mission & Goals
Bylaws (as amended October 21, 2020)
Strategic Plan
Diversity
AAPOR Conduct Policy
Donate/Gifts to AAPOR
Planned Giving
Become an AAPOR Sponsor
Conference Exhibits and Sponsorships
Year-round AAPOR Sponsorship Opportunities
Sustaining Sponsorship Program
Career Center
In Memoriam
Staff/Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Terms and Conditions of Use
Procedures for Requesting Removal of Infringing Material
Home
—>
Publications/Media
—>
AAPOR Press Releases
—>
Archived Press Releases
Insights and AAPOR File FCC Petition Seeking Legal Differentiation for Marketing and Research
WASHINGTON, DC, October 30, 2017
– Seeking to clarify the regulatory distinction between the intent to market and sell to individuals and the dissimilar intent to understand market needs, the Insights Association and AAPOR have filed a petition with the FCC to secure "greater clarity" that will be "critical to restoring a measure of sanity to TCPA litigation."
"Courts and trial lawyers are conflating marketing research with marketing to the detriment of survey, opinion and marketing research companies," said David W. Almy, CEO of the Insights Association. According to a petition filed today at the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), the agency needs to clarify that marketing research is separate and distinct from marketing for purposes of compliance with the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). "Research has a fundamentally different purpose than sales and marketing. That researchers have paid millions to settle an epidemic of TCPA lawsuits is unnecessary, unwarranted and very often absurd," Almy added.
The petition, filed by the Insights Association, the leading trade association for the market research and data analytics industry, and the American Association of Public Opinion Research (AAPOR), which promotes the sound and ethical conduct and use of public opinion research, requested a declaratory ruling from the FCC that:
communications should not be presumed to be advertising or marketing under the TCPA simply because they are sent by a for-profit company, or might ultimately be used at some future date to improve sales or customer relations;
the presence in a communication, ancillary document or webpage revealing the identity of an organization conducting research – a level of transparency required by professional ethical codes – that can be mischaracterized as "advertising" does not make the communication "dual-purpose";
the FCC’s "vicarious liability" regime applies only to telemarketing and debt collection, not to survey, opinion, and market research firms; and
survey, opinion, and marketing research studies are not goods or services provided to a research respondent, even if the studies involve an incentive for participation.
"Selling under the guise of research, or sugging, is a practice condemned by AAPOR," said Tim Johnson, AAPOR President. "It is incumbent on the FCC to differentiate between marketing research and marketing."
The petitioners noted some disturbing court decisions mistakenly "premised on the notion that businesses do not communicate with consumers except for the purpose of turning a profit," and urged the FCC to recognize that, like all for-profit businesses, market research companies advertise and market their services only to research sponsors – "the clients on whose behalf the research is conducted" – and not to research respondents.
Meanwhile, "the plaintiffs’ bar and some courts have begun using a loose interpretation of" FCC guidance to find hidden sales and marketing purposes inside marketing research phone calls and faxes.
The petitioners regularly combat sales under the guise of research, a deceptive practice known as "sugging" in the research industry, which would constitute "pretext" for sales or marketing under the FCC’s guidance. By contrast, the Insights Association and AAPOR called upon the FCC to clarify that an instance as simple as a survey mentioning a corporate client in a survey question, or a research company discussing its own services in a privacy policy or website separate from a research study, does not prove the existence of any "dual purpose" – the communications would still constitute research, not marketing.
Vicarious liability means that someone is held responsible for the actions or omissions of another person. The FCC has ruled before that calls placed by a telemarketer’s or debt collector’s agent should be treated as if the telemarketer or debt collector made the calls himself. The agency "could have simply stated that vicarious liability applies to all principal-agent relationships, but it did not do so," asserted the petitioners. A recent class action court decision applied that same vicarious liability regime to a research company and the petitioners asked the FCC to clarify that such liability only applies to telemarketing and debt collection.
The FCC has repeatedly said that marketing research is not telemarketing under the TCPA because research communications, in the words of the TCPA text, do not "[encourage] the purchase or rental of, or investment in, property, goods, or services." Similarly, the Insights Association and AAPOR asked the FCC to clarify that research studies themselves don’t "constitute property, goods, or services vis-à-vis the persons taking the surveys. These studies (and their results) are services provided to research clients, not consumers [who take surveys]." Although researchers often offer incentives for research participants in cash or prizes, "this is done only to ensure robust participation" in research studies.
“With researchers already preyed upon by trial lawyers thanks to the FCC’s 2015 TCPA rules,” commented Howard Fienberg, director of government affairs for the Insights Association, the FCC "can take these simple steps to limit class actions based on misunderstanding and mischaracterization of the raison d’etre of marketing research."
------------
The Insights Association is the leading trade association for the market research and data analytics industry. Inspired by the 2017 merger of CASRO and MRA, all Insights Association proceeds are invested in advocacy, education and other initiatives to directly support the marketing research and analytics community. Visit
www.insightsassociation.org
for more information.
The American Association for Public Opinion Research (AAPOR) is the leading professional organization of public opinion and survey research professionals in the U.S., with members from academia, media, government, the non-profit sector and private industry. AAPOR promotes the sound and ethical conduct and use of public opinion research. Visit
www.aapor.org
for more information.
READ THE FULL INSIGHTS ASSOCIATION / AAPOR PETITION TO THE FCC
My AAPOR
Membership
Publications/Media
Conference/Events
Standards/Ethics
Education/Resources
About Us
AAPOR Publications
POQ
JSSAM
Survey Practice
Standard Definitions
Reports
AAPOR Newsletter
April 2021
January 2021
October 2020
July 2020
March 2020
December 2019
October 2019
August 2019
June 2019
April 2019
February 2019
December 2018
October 2018
August 2018
June 2018
April 2018
February 2018
December 2017
October 2017
August 2017
June 2017
April 2017
February 2017
December 2016
October 2016
August 2016
June 2016
April 2016
February 2016
December 2015
November 2015
September 2015
July 2015
Newsletter Archives
AAPOR Press Releases
Archived Press Releases
AAPOR Statements
Use of AAPOR Logo
Member Login
Join AAPOR
Donate